Stay connected with Navado:
SYDNEY CBD    |    PARRAMATTA    |    CHATSWOOD    |    HURSTVILLE

Buying or selling a residential property?

With our Residential Conveyancing Offer, we offer fixed fees of $1650 (plus disbursements) for your purchase or sale. Conditions apply. | See more …

Have you been charged with a criminal or traffic offence?

We offer fixed fees from $1100 for one of our Lawyers to appear on one day at any Local Court in Sydney. Conditions apply. | See more …

Buying a property and need a home loan?

Our experienced Brokers can help you compare interest rates and home loans, at no cost to you in the comfort of your own home. | See more …

Do you need to lodge your personal Tax Return?

Our Public Accountants & Tax Agents charge a flat fee of $143 for your Individual salary or income tax returns. Conditions apply. | See more …

Secure your financial future. Plan today, enjoy tomorrow.

Create wealth. Minimise tax. Structured tailored solutions. Arrange a free consultation with a Financial Advisor today. Conditions apply. | See more …

You don't have a will? Don’t leave it until it’s too late...

We can help. Our lawyers will obtain an understanding of your situation and complete your simple will for $330. Conditions apply. | See more …

Conveyancing & Will Offer

Fixed fees of $1870 (plus disbursements) for the sale or purchase of residential property & a simple will. Conditions apply. | See more …

Are you thinking of setting up a Company?

For a fixed fee of $550 plus disbursements, our Public Accountants can help you complete the puzzle of Company Registration. | See more …

Going to Court? Strategy is key.

You may feel like you are all alone and that the odds are against you. Speak to one of our experienced Litigation Solicitors. | See more …

Get the right legal advice for your business.

When it comes to your business, precision is key. Speak to one of our experienced Business & Commercial Law Solicitors. | See more …

Do you have a civil or commercial dispute?

Our Litigation Lawyers focus on delivering cost effective, strategic solutions to your legal dispute. | See more …

What are your legal rights? Do you know where you stand?

Don’t feel discouraged. We can help. For an agreed fixed fee, we can provide you with a preliminary legal opinion. | See more …

Are you considering setting up a Trust?

For a fixed fee of $880 plus Disbursements, our Public Accountants can help you establish a Discretionary, Family, Hybrid or Unit Trusts. | See more …

Are you thinking of setting up an SMSF?

For a fixed fee of $550 plus disbursements, our Public Accountants can help you register your SMSF. Conditions apply. | See more …

Are you thinking of setting up a Business and Company?

For a fixed fee of $825 plus disbursements, our Public Accountants can help you register your Business & Company. Conditions apply. | See more …

Have you considered seeking Estate Planning legal advice?

We offer a special package of $990.00 including GST, for a simple Will, Power of Attorney and Enduring Guardianship. Conditons Apply. | See more …

Become a Navado Private client

Navado Legal & Financial Group can provide a total synergistic legal and financial solution tailored to your circumstances. | See more …

Previous
Next

Legal > Civil & Commercial Litigation

Caveat Disputes:

Overview FAQs Articles Locations

Disputes involving caveats are a subset of the law of property and cross over into the law of equity as well. Litigation involving caveats and caveatable interests can either be simple or very complex. Simple cases usually concern caveats over property which is used as some form of security for a debt or loan. Complex cases may involve situations where the interest on which a caveat is registered is in face caveatable, or where the loan itself is in question. In these cases, documents may need to be adduced which can evidence any agreement from which the caveatable interest arises. It is often the cases that such agreements are verbal, and this adds to the complexity of the problem. The general principles relating to the laws of contract may be of use here when determining the relevant legal issues in dispute. 

A caveat solicitor or a lawyer who is retained to deal with a legal dispute concerning caveats will therefore need to have the broad experience necessary to be able to perceive possible problem areas when considering a case for litigation. Disputes involving caveats may therefore involve processes that are connected to civil litigation as well as commercial litigation. The commercial litigation aspects may become more readily apparent where the caveat is somehow connected to a business or some commercial enterprise. The property may be part of a business, or the loan (the unpaid debt of which is secured by the caveat) may be for a business purpose, for example. The civil litigation aspects of the caveat may be connected to a personal dispute between parties who claim ownership of the property or part of the property. It is not unusual for a dispute concerning a caveat to have elements of both commercial and civil litigation in common. 

Some of the general issues and questions that arise in caveat disputes can include the following: 

  • Is there a caveatable interest?
  • Was consideration necessary for the caveat?
  • Was the consideration for the caveat sufficient, or was there some failure of consideration?
  • Was consent required for the caveat?
  • Was this consent obtained properly?
  • Is there a dispute of priorities between caveats?
  • How is the caveat to be removed?
  • Was the security sufficient?
  • Contractual interpretation.

A dispute of priorities between caveats will be determined according to equitable principles and property law. This usually involves a claim of right to have the value of the caveat secured first in line of a series of caveats. Interest in property can be legal or equitable, and there are rules in relation to which interest takes precedents over which other interest: whether it is legal against legal, legal against equitable, or equitable against equitable. Some exceptions apply in certain circumstances, but these need to be ascertained by a competent caveats property layer before action can be taken in Court.

If consideration is required for the caveat, and if that consideration has failed, it is likely that a an element of trust law may be relevant to resolving this dispute. This too will have to be investigated in detail before any action is taken. Disputes involving failed consideration may be fact heavy, and where there is not written contract, may well revolve around testimonial evidence in the form of affidavits, statements and declarations. These are sensitive matters and must be approached with caution. Where there is not written contract evidencing any agreement, inferences can be made from the testimonial evidence and the conduct of the parties.

Where there is a caveat on a property, generally that property cannot be sold or otherwise disposed of for value. An individual or a business which has a claim against the vendor of property can lodge and register a caveat over that property until the account has been settled between them. Often, the account is itself in dispute and the vendor will wish to remove the caveat so that the property can be transferred. Situations like these may require legal advice from a civil litigation lawyer who has had experience in commercial litigation because there may be issues in dispute that bridge both areas of legal practice. Likewise a commercial lawyer with civil litigation experience will be in a position to consider the case from a different perspective and therefore provide in depth analysis of the pending litigation. 

If you require assistance with a caveat litigation matter you may wish to contact our office and make an appointment to see one of our solicitors in our Sydney office. By appointment, we can also make a time for you to see one of our lawyers in one of our branch offices.

Bookmark and Share

This webpage (and any material or wording appearing on this webpage) is provided for general information purposes only and does not constitute any Legal Advice. It does not take into account your objectives, your instructions or all of the relevant facts and/or circumstances. Navado accepts no responsibility to any person who relies on the information provided on this website. We further refer you to our Disclaimer.

Sorry, but no Articles are available at this time.

Sorry, but no FAQs are available at this time.

If you require assistance with a matter, you should make an appointment to see one of our Lawyers in one of the following locations:

  • Sydney
  • Parramatta
  • Chatswood
  • Hurstville

Our Locations

  • Civil Lawyer Sydney
  • Commercial Lawyer Sydney
  • Civil Lawyer Parramatta
  • Commercial Lawyer Parramatta
  • Civil Lawyer North Sydney
  • Commercial Lawyer North Sydney
  • Civil Lawyer Hurstville
  • Commercial Lawyer Hurstville
  • Civil Lawyer Liverpool
  • Commercial Lawyer Liverpool
  • Civil Lawyer Gordon
  • Commercial Lawyer Gordon
  • Civil Lawyer Baulkham Hills
  • Commercial Lawyer Baulkham Hills
  • Civil Lawyer Campbelltown
  • Commercial Lawyer Campbelltown
  • Civil Lawyer Bondi Junction
  • Commercial Lawyer Bondi Junction
  • Civil Lawyer Chatswood
  • Commercial Lawyer Chatswood
  • Civil Lawyer Miranda
  • Commercial Lawyer Miranda
  • Civil Lawyer Bella Vista
  • Commercial Lawyer Bella Vista
  • Civil Lawyer Erina
  • Commercial Lawyer Erina
Quick enquiry
  • Request an appointment

Where to find us?

Sydney (Head Office)
Level 10, 309 Pitt Street.

Parramatta
Level 9, 33 Argyle Street.

Chatswood
Level 1, 10 Help Street.

Hurstville
Ground Floor, 5 Railway Parade.

In NSW, Interstate or International?
Initial Consultations are available by Skype or Tele-Conference.

Stay connected
Ask an expert